Pedro Martinez returned to the Major League mound tonight for the first time this season, and for his first start for a legitimate franchise since the Red Sox let him go after the 2004 season. Pedro’s start got me thinking of the old days when he was all but unhittable. He showed little glimpses of that briefly tonight, but in his prime, Pedro was something special.
So I started trying to rank him against other modern (guys who have spent the majority of their careers in the 90’s-2000’s) pitchers. These are my top 5.
By the way, to avoid controversy, or a grand jury investigation, I left Roger Clemens off this list. Probably would’ve been number 3ish anyways, but I never really liked the guy all that much.
2 Cy Youngs, 4 All Star Games, 1 Gold Glove
This guy is very good. He may have been the big reason the Twins were contenders in the early 2000’s, and if he was part of a better team now, his numbers would be unbelievable. A career era of 3.10 and a career WHIP at 1.11. That WHIP is 4th among active players (26th all time), two of the three ahead of him are on this list, the other is Trevor Hoffman. Not too shabby.
So he doesn’t give up hits, and doesn’t walk anybody, and strikes out a batter every inning. Tough to hit. If you looked at his career numbers for era, WHIP, and K/9 you would think he was a closer. Scariest stat: Born March 13, 1979.
No Cy Youngs, 10 all star games, 1 WS MVP, 1 ALCS MVP
10 years, and 4 rings Santana’s senior, Rivera has made a career out of one pitch. I almost put Rivera at number 1 because of that fact. Everyone knows what is coming and no one has figured him out. You can argue that he throws a 2 seamer and a little slider from time to time, but you could guess cutter every pitch, get it every pitch, and never hit the thing square.
If Elias sports bureau kept a stat for broken bats it would not even be close. The fact is, if his cutter moves enough it is virtually swingproof. There is very little chance of hitting something that moves that drastically from where a hitter last sees it. It is an angry flat slider (sounds like something off the Chili’s menu).
The stats you ask? Screw saves, Rivera’s WHIP is 3rd all time (1st Active), ERA is first among active players (14th all time), and to give you an idea of guys not being able to square it up, he gives up roughly one homerun every 19 innings (1st among active players).
5 Cy Youngs, 10 All Star Games, 1 WS MVP
Randy Johnson is a big, ugly, scary, ugly, big lefthander that no one ever liked to face. In his prime he had the fastball that looked like he was placing in the catcher’s mitt and the slider that a righty could swing through and then get hit in the back leg with.
300 K’s 6 times, 20 wins twice, a ton of innings, and, like Johan, closer numbers when it comes to WHIP (5th active). He is first all time in K’s per 9 innings at over 10, and for a guy with his power, he has never walked too many guys. When him and Schilling both pitched for the DBACKs they had two power guys that could go 8 innings everytime out. Scary. Too bad he spent so much of his career alone in Seattle. Poor Randy and Ken Griffey.
His 2002 line:
24 w’s, 5 L’s, 2.32 ERA, 8 CG’s, 4 SHO, 197 H’s in 260 IP, 334 K’s, for a WHIP of 1.03 and 11.6 K’s/9. All at the young age of 38. Those are Satchel Paige Numbers if you threw in 9 no hitters, and few good quotes, “Ain’t no man can avoid being born average, but there ain’t no man got to be common.” -Satch
4 Cy Youngs, 8 All Star Games, 18 Gold Gloves (just give me one to pawn)
If this was all based on purely statistics, Maddux would probably be a little lower on the list, but as far as pitching goes, Greg was world class. His Brave’s made a career for Leo Mazzone, who looked like a genius because of him, Smoltzy and Tom Glavine. Maddux just evolved as he went. He seemed to know how hitters thought, and always used that against him. He was the kind of pitcher guys probably saw warm up and got excited then couldn’t understand how they went 0-4 off of him.
3.16 career ERA. In 1994, he had 16 wins, 1.56 era, and a WHIP at .896 before the strike. The next season, 19-2, 1.63 ERA and a nonexistent WHIP of .811. Mark Lemke and Jeff Blauser probably could’ve left their gloves in the dugout. He was the best pitcher of the early 90’s and became one of the most consistent pitchers of all time. He won 15 or more games from 1988 to 2006. Pretty unbelievable career.
3 Cy Youngs, 8 All Star Games
Pedro reminds me of an old school pitcher. He is almost like the Ken Griffey Jr of pitchers in that he showed us what normal deterioration and aging look like in a non-roided up player. That says a lot of Randy Johnson, as well who is a freak of nature (an ugly one).
I grew up in the mix in Connecticut. Its kind of like the baseball Mason-Dixon there. Yankees and Sox fans get brutal during baseball season because there is no women’s basketball to calm them down. So when the Yanks-Sox series came on, it got heated. Pedro was “A #1” douchebag in this period of my life. He hit everybody on the Yanks, all the time. He knew he could because he could get anybody out. So why not drill Jeter in the brain or hit Tino between the numbers?
Speaking of numbers (wow, what a segway), Pedro’s career ERA of 2.91 is 3rd among active pitchers, and has been hurt because of his recent few seasons. He is first among active pitchers in winning percentage, 3rd all time in k/9 innings, and 6th all time in WHIP (3rd among active behind Hell’s Bells and the Sandman). Also 3rd among active pitchers in beaning dudes 137 times.
Martinez wanted the ball in big games, and had huge balls in those games. Too many people will remember Grady Little leaving him in and Hideki Matsui hitting a seed off him, but I think Pedro wouldn’t have it any other way.
Pedro is #1 because he is such a hybrid. He had the power stuff comparable to a Randy Johnson, about 10 different changeups that Santana will try to live up to, the floaty stuff from time to time that Maddux extended his career with, and the ability to just flat out get guys out that Mo has.
Pedro was, in his prime, the perfect modern pitcher.